JOURNAL INFORMATION
ISSN: 3059-846X
Frequency: Quarterly
Final Decision: 75 days
Plagiarism: <18%
Language: English
Review process: Double-blind
Open access: Yes
Copyright: CC BY 4.0
Make a Submission →At TSRJ, we highly value the contributions made by our peer reviewers to the academic community. Reviewers play a vital role in ensuring publication quality and advancing research within their fields of expertise.
The peer review process is a cornerstone of knowledge development across all disciplines. By reviewing, you help authors strengthen their manuscripts and gain early access to emerging work. Your efforts directly support the growth and progress of your field.
These pages provide all the guidance and resources you need to participate effectively in this important process.
Peer review is a process in which researchers (“peers”) assess the quality and validity of other researchers’ work to ensure rigor, logical soundness, and contribution to knowledge.
Peer review supports academic publishing by:
For more on peer review types, see Peer Review: The Nuts and Bolts of Peer Review .
Each TSRJ journal has its own guidelines and methods. Always check the journal’s instructions before reviewing.
Reviewer reports may be published alongside the article, providing insight into the process and giving recognition to reviewers and editors.
Visibility encourages thorough, constructive feedback and helps identify biases or inappropriate tone. This improves manuscript quality and reinforces credibility.
Peer review maintains research quality and integrity. TSRJ values reviewers’ contributions and offers recognition (e.g., discounts or complimentary access).
For new reviewers, the process can be challenging but rewarding—building skills and offering early insight into emerging research.
Once registered, editors may invite you to review. If you cannot accept, notify the editor promptly and suggest alternatives where possible.
See also the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers .
For comments on your reviewing experience or suggestions, email [email protected].
Upon successful completion of a course, participants receive a certificate of achievement.
Plain Language Summaries (PLS) make research understandable to non-specialists. When reviewing a PLS, check it: clearly communicates findings; avoids jargon or defines terms; accurately reflects the study; engages general readers; stays concise.
Short, accessible summaries placed after the abstract. They include:
Key points:
Non-specialists with lived experience or interest (e.g., related academics, patients, caregivers, students, policymakers, practitioners).
PLS reviewers reflect the audience perspective—helping ensure clarity, accuracy, and accessibility.
After registration, PLS reviewers receive a journal system account to access articles and submit feedback.
Recommendations: Accept (no changes) or Minor Revision (small edits). For serious concerns, use “Comments to the Editor.”
A format where peer review and conditional approval occur before data collection/analysis (pre-registration), in two stages.
Stage 1: Review protocol (intro/methods/analysis). If approved, authors receive In-Principle Acceptance (IPA). Stage 2: Authors complete the study as planned; reviewers assess adherence and clarity of reporting.
Outcomes: reject, revise, or IPA. Deviations later require editor approval; major changes need resubmission as new Stage 1.
Editorial decisions at Stage 2 focus on accuracy, adherence, and clarity — not on novelty or conclusiveness. Reference: Chambers, C. (2019). Nature, 573(7773), 187–189. 10.1038/d41586-019-02674-6
Consult the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and their Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers before beginning a review.
Raising concerns early helps maintain the integrity of the journal and the research record.
We appreciate our reviewers. TSRJ provides resources to support thorough, constructive reviews and acknowledges contributions.
Some journals publish annual reviewer acknowledgments—opt out by informing the editor.
Receive formal acknowledgment for your peer review contributions, and link your reviews to ORCID for additional recognition.
Need evidence for funding, promotion, jobs, or visas? Download your review record or provide your review confirmation emails.
ORCID maintains a public, verifiable record of your academic contributions. Link your ORCID to TSRJ reviews for Web of Science Reviewer Recognition, and follow ORCID’s guidance to maintain an authoritative profile.
ISSN: 3059-846X
Frequency: Quarterly
Final Decision: 75 days
Plagiarism: <18%
Language: English
Review process: Double-blind
Open access: Yes
Copyright: CC BY 4.0
Make a Submission →The journal is indexed or abstracted in







